Joined: 08 Aug 2003 Posts: 943 Location: Terra Firma, Ether Sea
Posted: Tue May 27, 2008 11:14 am Post subject:
Millibobs wrote:
don't get me started JZ ....... Just bought me a Fender DRRI which I'm going to collect on Thursday ...... mmmm ...... tone ....... need more tone ...........
Hi, MB.
A couple years back I started a thread about the meaning and use of the word "TONE"?
Now, I'm not ragging on you at all, or anything like that, but your use of "Tone" here kind of epitimizes MY confusion of the word's meaning when folks say they are looking for the "perfect tone".and thought you might be able to help me here in understanding what folks mean when they say they are searching for "tone".
What exactly do you mean when you use it here?
What is it about "tone" that you need more of....
Volume? (Does "tone" mean that your amp sounds the way you want, but that you need it to be louder? As when an ear doctor testing your hearing says, "Please raise your hand when you hear the tone and then put it back down when the tone goes away.") Bass, mids, or highs? Distortion? Clearity? Sustain? Punch? Thinness? Roundness? Warmth?
So, if I myself say "I need more 'tone'", are you and I speaking about the same thing?
Maybe this is my confusion with the word:
To me, "tone" is basically another generic word for "sound", usually accompanied with some sort of a discription such as, "loud tone", "quiet tone", "bell-like tone", "clear tone", "mono tone", "low tone", "hi tone", "droning tone", etc.
So, when someone tells me they need more tone (more sound = volume?), or that they are searching for the "perfect tone" (the perfect "sound"?), what is that supposed to mean to me when what I consider perfect sounds (tones), is probably something entirely different from what the other person is speaking of.
If I'm told that someone is looking for an amp with perfect tone, and I suggest a Rickenbacker 360/12 thru a Vox AC30 clean channel, but the other person thinks the sound of an Ibenez guitar thru a stack of Marshall linked channel amps is what he is what is the perfect sound, aren't we speaking in two different ballparks?
So which one truly has the "perfect tone"?
Anyway, this is my quandry... I really don't understand what this "tone" is that everyone is searching for (especially "perfect" tone). Seems to me it's different for everyone and therefore there is no "perfect" tone.
So, if someone says they need "Tone" or are trying to duplicate "perfect tone", what exactly am I supposed to hear in my head?
What IS "Perfect tone" and what is it about it that makes it "perfect", better than any other sound?
"Tone, I just wish I could get more TONE out of my amp or guitar".... ????
What is that supposed to mean to me?
Sorry, but I just don't get it.
Thanks CJ - this one has the JJ's in already - he's clearly a man of taste!
Daved, I can tell you exactly what 'tone' means:
it is:
* the sound that came off Robbens's amps at last week's gig in Manchester UK ( a Twin and a Super Reverb)
* the irresistible expressions of happiness and helpless joy around the room as he trotted out his trademark songs, licks and vocals (he is a bloody fantastic singer - fact)
* The mood of the gig - I could tell who was a guitar player, who simply liked his stuff, who was there by mistake, simply from the reactions and comments. Whatever the different perceptions, the 'tone' of that room was reverential, loving and affectionate - I caught a couple of guys, like me, who were just overcome by what RF was doing. Nothing much makes me emotional or makes the tears flow apart from my kids and a kick in the balls, but when I got home and thought about what I'd just witnessed and what it meant to me personally, I actually found myself snivelling - it seems cheesy but the only thing that has been a constant in my life from around 11 years old is the guitar - it is fundamentally a part of my persona and I think Robben would understand this - it's the 'tone' of my life
* Whilst Robben has very little to say to the audience, the 'tone' is one of mutual respect. Both parties know what is expected and Robben delivers the goods. Some would call it clinical or sterile - I would call it 'quality' - you get exactly what you paid for but something comes bundled for free - 'tone'
* Seeing Robben in person for the first (but hopefully not the last) time, made me want to get straight back on the guitar and play. It set the 'tone' for my next recording and playing activities
I always thought that the tone I was looking for was a sound but in fact, it's far more than that - it is a way of playing that makes you feel like when you were a kid at the Saturday cinema, running up the aisles - like you were running on air, just above ground level. I think this is what 'tone' is - it's a feeling, a sense of sitting just outside reality and it's as real as any sense of smell or taste. It's the fifth sense! Touch, taste, sight, sound - TONE!!!!!!!!
Joined: 03 May 2008 Posts: 15 Location: Northern Ireland
Posted: Tue May 27, 2008 2:34 pm Post subject:
I agree with both you guys regarding "tone".
Daved - I agree that "tone" (as in "I love the tone I got during that last set") is not only an entirely subjective thing but also a moving target. Personally, I know that "my tone" is mostly the way I touch the guitar combined with knowing what tools I need to get the job done. Do I want or need "more tone"? Like Daved I don't know what that means, but I always want to have the best possible "version" of "my tone" even if everyone else thinks it stinks! I know now what works for me and, dare I say it, the "tonequest" is over - no excuses now not to just get on and play well!
David - you've touched on something else and an interesting meaning of "tone". The "tone" of the performance and the interaction between performer and audience. It brings to mind "Zen Guitar".
Going back to "tone" and Robben - I think that these recent shows prove that tone is within you. In your touch and your perception of sound. Robben plugs into a Dumble personalised for him through his choice of speakers, or a RI Twin & Super or (as I saw last week) a new Twin with all the bells & whistles and a scruffy SF Twin and still sounds exactly like Robben Ford - sublime
Joined: 17 Jul 2003 Posts: 908 Location: Tampa Bay, FL
Posted: Thu May 29, 2008 4:38 am Post subject:
I am surprised at how poorly I tested, especially on the visual symbolic intelligence test -- how well you hear shapes. My ears must have a mind of their own! _________________ Travelling by train of thought
Posted: Fri May 30, 2008 2:49 am Post subject: tone deaf
roadwarriorfortheblues wrote:
I am surprised at how poorly I tested, especially on the visual symbolic intelligence test -- how well you hear shapes. My ears must have a mind of their own!
1st) I did 88.9 , i don't want to show off but i had to answer phone , i
didn't plug good speakers , 'nuff said i was not focused. But it was fun & easy for a so called "musician".
2nd) Shapes i did 55 % so don't worry ......
TONE DEAF : Yes i am . But i knew it . A whole range of frequencies have disappeared from my perception . (If it's too loud you are too old)
4th) don't remember .
I think i'll do it again with good speakers & no hassling.
Once again RW you always have a good link, hint, Like said Billy Mobs
Joined: 29 Jan 2004 Posts: 1504 Location: Methuen, MA
Posted: Tue Jun 24, 2008 10:55 am Post subject:
It's been a while since I listened to Lateral Climb, so when I put it on in the car this morning on my way to work and it got to the phrase "coffee, keys, and I'm on my way" I mentally substituted "quiche" for "keys" and had a good laugh!
Actually, I noticed later on in the song when Robben repeats the phrase that "keys" is much clearer and definitely doesn't sound like "tea" or "quiche" or whatever else people's twisted minds decided it sounded like...
All times are GMT - 8 Hours Goto page Previous1, 2, 3Next
Page 2 of 3
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum